It is a measure of the ‘post-truth’ world we live in that Mersal, a Tamil commercial film that purports to convey a social message, plays fast and loose with easily verifiable facts about the Goods and Services Tax in respect of the healthcare industry. The claptrap dialogues mouthed by protagonist Vijay may not withstand the scrutiny of fact-checkers, but they have played well with gullible audiences for whom nuance in narratives is an expendable luxury. And particularly since the complexities of the GST framework have bamboozled even domain experts, the space has been opened up for ill-informed commentary with pseudo-intellectual pretensions to masquerade as pop-sociological critique. Mersal fills that space with a slick storyline.
Even so, the response of the State unit of the BJP — in calling for the politically sensitive dialogues in Mersal to be censored — is ham-handed and represents a disdain for freedom of artistic expression. The doctrine of free speech dictates that Mersal has a right to be wrong. Even more venomous is the BJP leaders’ attempt to give the controversy a communal hue by pointedly alluding to the lead actor as ‘Joseph Vijay’, insinuating that the BJP is the target of a Christian ‘hate campaign’. These prickly leaders will be better served by reflecting on the reasons for the GST’s unpopularity and why even half-baked on-screen criticism resonates thunderously with audiences.
No comments:
Post a Comment